- USDT(TRC-20)
- $0.0
The latest trend on TikTok is hyping up the benefits of hydrogen water while attempting to sell you a battery-powered water bottle that produces it. Does hydrogen water really hydrate you better and cure your gut issues? Do those bottles even make hydrogen water?
Leaving TikTok aside for the moment, letās talk about what it means for your water to have hydrogen in it. A water molecule is made of one oxygen atom bound to two hydrogen atoms, hence its chemical formula: H2O.
But thatās not the hydrogen theyāre talking about. Hydrogen can also be a gas, where two hydrogen molecules are bound to each other. The chemical formula for that is H2. Hydrogen gas is lightweight; itās also flammable, as famously demonstrated in the Hindenburg disaster.
Hydrogen water, also called hydrogenated water, is water that has hydrogen gas bubbled through it. The gas will want to float into the air, so itās hard to actually keep the hydrogen in the water; leaving it uncapped will allow the gas escape, much like carbon dioxide bubbles float away if you leave a soda uncapped and it goes flat.
All this is to say: Hydrogen water is a real thing that can be manufactured. Whether itās being manufactured appropriately in these TikToks, and whether itās responsible for any health benefits, is harder to say.
Scrolling through the videos tagged #hydrogenwater#hydrogenwatertching the classic āsell me this pencilā improv exercise. Each creator shows a bottle that glows blue when you press a button, and each enthuses over it for a different reason. One tells us how good the water tastes. One calls it āsacred water.ā One says she expects it to cure her gut-health issues. One says itās the most āhydratingā type of water.
Several of these clips feature all-star huckster Gary Brecka, who claims there are 1,400 human studies on the benefits of hydrogen water. If there are, theyāre really well hidden! But more on that in a minute.
These videos are all light on the backing for their claims, and heavy on the sales pitch: where to get the bottle with the blue light, how much it costs, why this model is better than that one, and so on.
The few human studies out there are limited in scope and not very conclusive in their results. For example, hereās one on whether hydrogenated water improves how cancer patients feel after radiation. The patients who drank the hydrogenated water reported better quality-of-life scores, but there were no changes in health outcomes such as tumor size. Hereās another showing a small possible effect on blood lipids such as LDL, but itās a small study and the authors acknowledge several limitations.
These studies are great as a starting point for further research, but they donāt constitute proof that hydrogen water is good for you. Note that they donāt measure any health outcomes (like occurrence of disease, rates of death, or anything similarly objective).
These studies also say nothing about battery-powered water bottles influencing any of the health outcomes theyāre being touted for, like hydration or gut health. That fact is more than enough to dismiss these claims out of hand, but before I close, Iād like to take a closer look at that bottle theyāre all trying to sell me.
Nearly all of the trending videos are hawking what looks like the same bottle. It appears to be the same design as this one, which is currently available on Amazon for about $30, and going for anywhere between $9 and $50 on TikTokās āshopā page.
This is in contrast to the way hydrogen water was produced in the studies I linked above. In those, participants were given magnesium sticks to drop into their water bottles for about 12 hours. Water reacts with magnesium to produce hydrogen gas and magnesium oxide; that's a pretty straightforward chemical reaction. But the TikTok version uses a water bottle with a button on it. You press the button, a blue light turns on, and tiny bubbles(?) appear in the water.
Iām highly skeptical of the claim that this produces any significant amount of hydrogen gas. Supposedly the bottom section of the bottle contains an electrolysis gadget, which uses electricity to separate water molecules into their hydrogen and oxygen components. The hydrogen atoms pair up with each other to make hydrogen gas, and the oxygen molecules pair up to make oxygen gas.
Creating a device to do this is a classic science experiment for kids. But is it really happening in that water bottle? First, if it were, it wouldnāt be hydrogen water, but rather hydrogen-and-oxygen water. Since hydrogen water is (sometimes) touted for its antioxidant properties, it would be strange to pair it with oxygen, a literal oxidant. And second, turning the water into gas would result in less water, as the water is converted into gas and the gasāunless tightly cappedāfloats away.
Some of the TikTokers attempt to measure the hydrogen content of the water, but they do so with pH meters, which measure hydrogen ions (not molecular hydrogen in the form of a gas). ORP devices face a similar problem: They donāt actually tell you how much hydrogen is in the water, just its redox potential. Adding to my skepticism, the bottleās description says you can use it with distilled water. You canāt do electrolysis on distilled water, since you need some salt or other source of ions to entice the water molecules to split apart in the first place.
So while I cannot prove that these bottles are bullshit, they sure donāt sound very legit. And while I also cannot prove that hydrogen water has zero health benefits, there sure isnāt anybody out there presenting strong evidence that they do. Save your money and try a TikTok trend that will actually improve your life, like angry cleaning.
Full story here:
What is hydrogen water?
Leaving TikTok aside for the moment, letās talk about what it means for your water to have hydrogen in it. A water molecule is made of one oxygen atom bound to two hydrogen atoms, hence its chemical formula: H2O.
But thatās not the hydrogen theyāre talking about. Hydrogen can also be a gas, where two hydrogen molecules are bound to each other. The chemical formula for that is H2. Hydrogen gas is lightweight; itās also flammable, as famously demonstrated in the Hindenburg disaster.
Hydrogen water, also called hydrogenated water, is water that has hydrogen gas bubbled through it. The gas will want to float into the air, so itās hard to actually keep the hydrogen in the water; leaving it uncapped will allow the gas escape, much like carbon dioxide bubbles float away if you leave a soda uncapped and it goes flat.
All this is to say: Hydrogen water is a real thing that can be manufactured. Whether itās being manufactured appropriately in these TikToks, and whether itās responsible for any health benefits, is harder to say.
What TikTok says about hydrogen water
Scrolling through the videos tagged #hydrogenwater#hydrogenwatertching the classic āsell me this pencilā improv exercise. Each creator shows a bottle that glows blue when you press a button, and each enthuses over it for a different reason. One tells us how good the water tastes. One calls it āsacred water.ā One says she expects it to cure her gut-health issues. One says itās the most āhydratingā type of water.
Several of these clips feature all-star huckster Gary Brecka, who claims there are 1,400 human studies on the benefits of hydrogen water. If there are, theyāre really well hidden! But more on that in a minute.
These videos are all light on the backing for their claims, and heavy on the sales pitch: where to get the bottle with the blue light, how much it costs, why this model is better than that one, and so on.
What the science says about hydrogen water
The few human studies out there are limited in scope and not very conclusive in their results. For example, hereās one on whether hydrogenated water improves how cancer patients feel after radiation. The patients who drank the hydrogenated water reported better quality-of-life scores, but there were no changes in health outcomes such as tumor size. Hereās another showing a small possible effect on blood lipids such as LDL, but itās a small study and the authors acknowledge several limitations.
These studies are great as a starting point for further research, but they donāt constitute proof that hydrogen water is good for you. Note that they donāt measure any health outcomes (like occurrence of disease, rates of death, or anything similarly objective).
These studies also say nothing about battery-powered water bottles influencing any of the health outcomes theyāre being touted for, like hydration or gut health. That fact is more than enough to dismiss these claims out of hand, but before I close, Iād like to take a closer look at that bottle theyāre all trying to sell me.
Does the bottle even do what itās saying?
Nearly all of the trending videos are hawking what looks like the same bottle. It appears to be the same design as this one, which is currently available on Amazon for about $30, and going for anywhere between $9 and $50 on TikTokās āshopā page.
This is in contrast to the way hydrogen water was produced in the studies I linked above. In those, participants were given magnesium sticks to drop into their water bottles for about 12 hours. Water reacts with magnesium to produce hydrogen gas and magnesium oxide; that's a pretty straightforward chemical reaction. But the TikTok version uses a water bottle with a button on it. You press the button, a blue light turns on, and tiny bubbles(?) appear in the water.
Iām highly skeptical of the claim that this produces any significant amount of hydrogen gas. Supposedly the bottom section of the bottle contains an electrolysis gadget, which uses electricity to separate water molecules into their hydrogen and oxygen components. The hydrogen atoms pair up with each other to make hydrogen gas, and the oxygen molecules pair up to make oxygen gas.
Creating a device to do this is a classic science experiment for kids. But is it really happening in that water bottle? First, if it were, it wouldnāt be hydrogen water, but rather hydrogen-and-oxygen water. Since hydrogen water is (sometimes) touted for its antioxidant properties, it would be strange to pair it with oxygen, a literal oxidant. And second, turning the water into gas would result in less water, as the water is converted into gas and the gasāunless tightly cappedāfloats away.
Some of the TikTokers attempt to measure the hydrogen content of the water, but they do so with pH meters, which measure hydrogen ions (not molecular hydrogen in the form of a gas). ORP devices face a similar problem: They donāt actually tell you how much hydrogen is in the water, just its redox potential. Adding to my skepticism, the bottleās description says you can use it with distilled water. You canāt do electrolysis on distilled water, since you need some salt or other source of ions to entice the water molecules to split apart in the first place.
So while I cannot prove that these bottles are bullshit, they sure donāt sound very legit. And while I also cannot prove that hydrogen water has zero health benefits, there sure isnāt anybody out there presenting strong evidence that they do. Save your money and try a TikTok trend that will actually improve your life, like angry cleaning.
Full story here:
![[DK]](/data/avatars/s/57/57999.jpg?1720990206){kind=avatar}
